Forget Costco. Save Money Shopping Here Instead

Image source: Getty Images

Between the rotisserie chicken, food court options, and their sample carts, Costco has achieved near-cult status. Where else can you get enough ketchup to make it through the apocalypse or find a comfortable couch for under $1,200?

It’s an easy place to rack up travel points, too. And then, of course, there’s the food court. What’s a trip to Costco without a cheap hot dog or slice of pizza?

For business owners and people with tons of storage space, Costco usually can’t be beat. But is it the best place to save cash? It might not be, depending on how you shop.

Costco makes it easy to overspend

I have a list of items I always get at Costco, like my favorite dairy-free buffalo sauce, rice, and ketchup. But it’s also really easy for me to overspend. Costco is about half an hour from my house, so I only go once every few months. As a result, I tend to over-do the stocking up.

Sometimes, I forget that I have three extra jars of Better Than Bouillon in the basement or a massive bag of chicken nuggets in the freezer. Five pounds of peaches sounds like a great idea, but I often don’t eat them before they start going bad. Add in the clothing, books, and toiletries section and I’m lucky to get out of Costco for less than $600.

If you break down prices by ounce, Costco is often the cheaper option — but not always. Plus, if you end up overspending on perishable goods or making impulse purchases, there might be options that are cheaper in the long run.

Aldi offers low-cost groceries and household items

If you have access to Aldi, it can be a great substitute for Costco. Like Costco, store-branded items are often far cheaper than name brands at the regular grocery store. For example, I can get 100 tablets of ibuprofen at Aldi for $1.99, which works out to $0.019 per tablet. Costco charges $12.99 for 1,000 tablets, which comes out to $0.012 per tablet, which isn’t much of a difference.

Many Aldi stores also have a good section of dairy-free and gluten-free items, which can be pricey at regular stores and hard to find at Costco.

The Aldi Finds section offers seasonal, limited-time items like pool floats, seasonal gnome decorations, rain boots, and snow pants. These items change every week and are often far cheaper than Costco or any other stores. For example, I spent $100 on Columbia hiking boots that ended up pinching my toes, but my $12 hiking boots from Aldi have hiked dozens of miles with no problem at all.

Local grocery stores often beat beat Costco prices

Not every city has an Aldi, or it might not be convenient to you. But there’s a good chance you have an even cheaper option closer to home. Small, local grocery stores are often affordable and stock a wide variety of items.

In my corner of Ohio, we have Marc’s. The stores are smaller than Costco and most grocery stores, but offer a wide selection of items. Its closeout section offers everything from school supplies and t-shirts to pet beds. Most of these items are bought from Target or similar stores when it swaps out stock for the season.

I regularly find Justice and Cat and Jack kids’ clothing for less than $2 per piece. While Marc’s doesn’t sell 2,000 tablets of Ibuprofen, I can get off-brand cold and flu medicine for less than $5 a bottle, while Costco charges $29.99 for a three-pack of DayQuil and NightQuil.

Marc’s is only in Ohio, but most cities have local grocery stores with similar pricing. When I lived in Chicago, for example, our local neighborhood market did.

If you find yourself struggling to stay on budget at Costco, look around your neighborhood for a locally owned grocery store. They don’t always offer the selection (or the cheap rotisserie chickens) you’ll find at Costco, but they are usually very affordable — and you won’t be tempted to buy that $1,000 patio set. For the samples and the food court pizza, however, you’ll have to make the trek to Costco.

Top credit cards to use at Costco (and everywhere else!)

If you’re shopping with a debit card, you could be missing out on hundreds or even thousands of dollars each year. These versatile credit cards offer huge rewards everywhere, including Costco, and are rated the best cards of 2024 by our experts because they offer hefty sign-up bonuses and outstanding cash rewards. Plus, you’ll save on credit card interest because all of these recommendations include a competitive 0% interest period.

Click here to read our expert recommendations for free!

We’re firm believers in the Golden Rule, which is why editorial opinions are ours alone and have not been previously reviewed, approved, or endorsed by included advertisers. The Ascent does not cover all offers on the market. Editorial content from The Ascent is separate from The Motley Fool editorial content and is created by a different analyst team.The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Costco Wholesale and Target. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.