Merging Loyalty and Gift Card Programs for an Optimal Holiday Shopping Season

With no relief from inflation in sight, consumers are bracing for an expensive holiday shopping season, especially with only 27 days between Thanksgiving and Christmas this year.

To stretch their budgets, consumers will leverage every available method, and merchants’ loyalty programs can save customers money while strengthening brand relationships. However, another key pillar of a merchant’s successful holiday strategy is its gift card program.

In a recent PaymentsJournal podcast, Tom Niedbalski, Vice President, Global Sales and Partnerships at Fiserv, and Jordan Hirschfield, Director of Prepaid at Javelin Strategy & Research, discussed the convergence of gift cards, loyalty programs, and technology—and the opportunities this creates for merchants in the upcoming holiday season.

Tighter budgets have driven consumers to shop earlier and spread out their purchases, a trend that retailers have encouraged with events like Prime Day. Consumers are also expected to take advantage of upcoming events like Black Friday and Cyber Monday.

Loyalty programs greatly influence where consumers shop during the holidays, as savvy customers use them to bolster their holiday spending. That’s why major retailers like Target, Walmart, and Amazon continuously drive engagement with their loyalty programs; it directly encourages consumers to participate in sales and promotions.

Gift cards should also be integrated into a merchant’s loyalty program. For example, a customer might receive a gift card for spending a certain amount or redeeming a specific number of reward points. However, a merchant’s gift card program takes on added importance during the holiday season.

“Gift cards have become the most popular gift,” Hirschfield said. “Roughly 63% of consumers say they will buy a gift card this holiday season, and 16% expect to spend more than last year. A loyalty program that is tied in with gift cards not only helps buyers purchase the items they need, but it’s also an inducement to purchase gift cards for others during the holiday season and beyond.”

Omnichannel Experience

Brands need to meet customers where they shop and pay, so merchants must invest significant time ensuring their mobile experience includes payments, loyalty, and gift cards in an omnichannel wallet.

“The digital experience not only allows the brand to interact with its consumers, but consumers can see the value of interacting with the brand,” Niedbalski said. “For years, I’ve been saying that stored value is the vehicle that drives transactions out of interactions and interactions out of transactions. It’s a two-way street.”

A digital wallet can also serve as the platform for merchants to offer innovative loyalty programs, such as product-specific promotions. For instance, if a customer buys a particular product, they might receive a gift card from the manufacturer to buy related accessories.

Another growing trend is self-use, and consumers who use gift cards for themselves are heavily influenced by loyalty programs.

“It creates a cycle of promotions, and it all links back to the phone,” Hirschfield said. “The mobile phone holds a customer’s stored value account and their payment methods. The physical gift card is still the top seller, but nearly a third of consumers will redeem a gift card in a mobile app. That number is only going to grow.”

Personalization vs. Privacy

Gift card personalization is a powerful way to connect with different demographics. With many faiths celebrating during the holidays, it’s important for merchants to cater to the diversity of their customer base.

Some brands have started offering print-on-demand gift cards. In the past decade, there has been a shift from traditional Christmas cards to postcards featuring personal images. This same concept is now applied to gift cards, allowing consumers to upload a family photo and include it with their gift.

“It connects with consumers, and these designs jump off the shelves, or the pegs, if you will,” Niedbalski said. “With e-commerce, there are a substantial amount of personalization options that give the gift a life of its own. Senders can include a written personal message, or they can send a voice message for friends and family in different areas.”

While personalization is a powerful tool, merchants should be cautious not to ask for too much personal data. Over half of consumers have distanced themselves from brands that request excessive information or send too many notifications.

“By nature, gift cards are incredibly private for the recipient—they can choose to utilize the card’s value without disclosing any personal information,” Hirschfield said. “That’s where merchants must strike a balance. They need to capture some customer data, but they don’t want to push too hard.”

Maximizing Visibility

With a wide range of products and services available in-store, many merchants can often struggle to boost gift card visibility. However, as the holiday season nears, in-store gift card displays can be highly effective. Equally important is catering to online shoppers—gift cards should be prominently featured in website banners, included in customer email campaigns, and promoted across social media channels.

Merchants should also ensure proper in-store placement and signage for gift cards, and maintain sufficient inventory to compensate for stockouts on other merchandise. Gift card displays don’t have to be limited to the point of purchase; there’s a growing trend of retailers offering themed gift cards in each department.

“Imagine a sporting goods store, and in the golf section you have golf-themed gift cards, and in the athletic shoe section you have shoe-themed gift cards,” Niedbalski said. “You’re giving the consumer multiple points of purchase. Maybe they can’t find the item they want, but instead of leaving the store, they purchase a gift card.”

Improving gift card visibility can also mitigate fraud and theft. Criminals often take gift cards off the rack, steal their data, and return them. If cards are in an unmonitored location, it creates risk for both consumers and merchants.

“This is a perfect time of year for merchants to retrain their staffs, especially if they are hiring temporary help,” Niedbalski said. “Employees should know how to spot suspicious behavior and check gift card packaging for tampering, even at the point of sale. Fraud is a threat in the gift card marketplace, but oftentimes it can be avoided if a merchant’s staff knows what to look for.”

Flawless Execution

Persistent inflation and the shortened holiday season make it critical for merchants to develop a holiday strategy now. That means establishing early holiday promotions and marketing them through appropriate channels.

“The key for all merchants is to create a plan early and execute it flawlessly,” Niedbalski said. “By running deeper promotions with longer promotional windows, it will not only encourage consumers to purchase gift cards for the financial benefits, but it’s also going to drive consumer loyalty. That will help merchants both retain existing customers and acquire new customers for their brand.”

Learn More About Fiserv Stored Value and Loyalty