Carnival is known for ultra-cheap cruises. I sailed on its new ship — and I’m not sure that’s completely true.

• Carnival Cruise Line is well known for its relatively affordable fares.
• But my recent Carnival Firenze cruise was filled with enticing pay-to-play amenities.
• Even the complimentary venues had up-charged options, making it easy for travelers to blow past their budget.

If you aren’t careful, your Carnival cruise could quickly become as expensive as an Oceania one.

Peruse any of the “US’ most budget-friendly cruise lines” lists, and you’re sure to find Carnival somewhere near the top. In 2024, its most affordable itinerary is $164 per person for a four-night sailing from Miami — more than $20 cheaper than Royal Caribbean and Norwegian’s least expensive ones.