Gift-Giving Is My Love Language, and I’m Shopping These 10 Personalized Finds for Mother’s Day From $4

In my family, it’s no secret that I’m the best gifter; everyone asks me for ideas whenever a holiday rolls around, and it’s quickly become one of my favorite tasks. Being thoughtful and sentimental is basically my love language.

I also like to support small businesses, and Mother’s Day is a perfect opportunity to find one-of-a-kind pieces from less widely known artists. Etsy has so many unique pieces for up to 60 percent off, including birth flower necklaces, personalized book stamps, and engraved kitchen spoons that I’ll be shopping this year (hey mom, stop reading — thanks!) 

Keep scrolling for my top 10 small-business gift picks at Etsy to shop this Mother’s Day. 

Custom Mother’s Day Gifts at Etsy 

• LoveSuna Personalized Mama Sweatshirt, $23.97–$32.55 (orig. $39.95)
• RhodonCo Stackable Birth Flower Necklace, $28.99–$58.99
• PetPartyCo Customized Dog Oven Mitt, $22.09 (orig. $33.99)
• StampByMeStudio Custom Book Stamp, $8.39 (orig. $11.99)
• 77Arts Embroidered Felt Bookmark, $3.67 (orig. $9.17)
• MyLittleBelleville Lavender Gardening Gloves, $17.25 (orig. $23)
• TomDesign Initials Necklace, $27.20 (orig. $34)
• TheCocoStudioAu Custom Family Birth Flower Illustration, $43.51–$107.52 (orig. $58.02–$143.36)
• TheNorthernPine Retro Motel Mom Keychain, $5.39 (orig. $5.99)
• SunshineLaserCo Custom Engraved Wood Stirring Spoon, $6.99 (orig. $9.32)

LoveSuna Personalized Mama Sweatshirt, $24 (Save 40%)

I firmly believe you can never go wrong with giving cozy loungewear. This subtle yet sentimental crewneck sweatshirt is available in white, black, sand, gray, and military green. It features the word ‘mama’ in varsity font on the front and has a customizable sleeve for adding additional names of children or pets for a personal touch. 

RhodonCo Stackable Birth Flower Necklace

For a unique take on a birthstone necklace, this stackable necklace is “delicate and beautifully made,” according to one shopper. Each pendant features pressed flowers in durable resin with an 18-karat gold-plated chain that can be worn solo or with several pendants stacked together.

PetPartyCo Customized Dog Oven Mitt, $23 (Save 35%)

Once my siblings and I moved out of my parents’ home, we were immediately replaced with dogs. Since they’re my mom’s babies, too, I know this customizable dog oven mitt would warrant a wave of excitement for Mother’s Day. It’s available in a single, right-hand style and 29 different patterns. I’ll probably even buy one for myself since I’m a proud dog mom, too. 

StampByMeStudio Custom Book Stamp, $9 (Save 30%)

For something thoughtful and one-of-a-kind, this custom book stamp is a genius gift for an avid reader with their own growing library. Choose from five different designs that can be personalized with their name. It comes in three stamp types: a solo wood stamp, a self-inking stamp, and a wood stamp and ink pad set. One shopper called it “a lovely item” to have in their home library. 

Keep scrolling for more Mother’s Day gift ideas from Etsy. 

77Arts Embroidered Felt Bookmark, $4 (Save 60%)

MyLittleBelleville Lavender Gardening Gloves, $18 (Save 25%)

TheCocoStudioAu Custom Family Birth Flower Illustration, $44 (Save 25%)

SunshineLaserCo Custom Engraved Wood Stirring Spoon, $7 (Save 25%)