Shop the 20 best jewelry pieces from Blue Nile before the holidays

As the holidays draw near, you’re likely shopping for the perfect gift for your partner. However, this season may be even more special than in years past, especially if you’re thinking about a proposal.

With more family gatherings and magic in the air, it’s the quintessential time to pop the question. According to The Knot, the holidays are the peak season for couples looking to get engaged. “In the U.S., 37% of engagements happen between November to February, and the new Global Wedding Report data shows that even within that time frame, December is the most popular month to propose.”

What better way to begin your diamond search than with Blue Nile. The revered online jewelry retailer offers a premium buffet of stones, settings and sparkles to suit your S.O. So, the Post Wanted team rounded up the best deals on rings — and other fine jewelry — for you to shop from to beat the holiday rush — without compromising quality.

Beyond engagement rings, Blue Nile has a repertoire of fine jewelry to choose from, including diamond earrings, tennis bracelets and stunning pendants. As far as both cocktail and engagement rings, you’ll enjoy Blue Nile’s wide selection of lab-grown options and three-stone rings as well.

Specifically, lab-created diamonds have the same optical, chemical and physical properties as natural diamonds. However, they are less expensive and make larger-size diamonds more affordable.

Ahead, we pulled Blue Nile’s finest pieces below. With all of these stunning options, holiday shopping is made easy this year.

Click to jump to a specific section:

Engagement Rings | Bracelets | Earrings | Necklaces

Engagement Rings

Petite Solitaire Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold

Simple and elegant, the Petite Solitaire Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold is one of our top picks, especially if you’re looking for a premium setting offered at an incredible value. Available in a variety of finishes, it’s a petite yet gorgeous ring that’s ready for your center stone of choice.

Twisted Halo Diamond Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold

Add some design to your ring with the Twisted Halo Diamond Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold that’s less than $2,000 to appeal to budget-conscious shoppers. Additionally, the ring features an elegant drape of pavé-set diamonds around the center stone and along the twisting shank for an alluring look.

Pear-Shaped Diamond Detail Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold

One of our favorite shapes for diamonds is the timeless pear, and Blue Nile’s Pear-Shaped Diamond Detail Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold is just shy of $1,000 and ready to be purchased for your special someone. With three petite diamonds flanking each side of the center stone, it’s a lovely choice.

Oval Three-Stone Diamond Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold

Shop the Oval Three-Stone Diamond Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold if your special someone has been hinting about having more than one diamond on her engagement ring. Though a splurge, it’s well worth the cost, as it’s also available in a variety of metals. Not to mention, it’s crowned with a brilliant center stone framed by two oval diamonds totaling 1 carat.

Vintage Diamond Halo Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold

Decades-lasting and captivating in every way, the Vintage Diamond Halo Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold is one of our favorite engagement rings to buy from Blue Nile ahead of the holiday season. Namely, the double diamond halo surrounds the center diamond of your choice, finished with a sparkling floral-themed motif.

Bracelets

Diamond Accent Bangle Bracelet in 14K Yellow Gold

If you don’t want to spend upwards of $10,000 on a tennis bracelet, the Diamond Accent Bangle Bracelet in 14K Yellow Gold is a lovely choice to buy as a splurge-worthy holiday gift. We love this brilliant timepiece because it features large and small diamonds that add some dimension and beautiful appeal.

Byzantine Bracelet in 18K Italian Yellow Gold

Chic and remarkably versatile, the Byzantine Bracelet in 18K Italian Yellow Gold is perfect for the yellow gold jewelry lover you know. The accessory boasts alternating textured and polished, hollow 18k Italian gold links to create a historical-inspired pattern.

Alternating Akoya and Gold Bead Bracelet in 14K Yellow Gold

Don’t be afraid to mix metals and materials. The Alternating Akoya and Gold Bead Bracelet in 14K Yellow Gold proves that both gold and pearls are a match made in heaven — oh, and a less-than-$1,000 purchase we stand behind.

Pavé Lab Grown Diamond Fashion Bangle in 14K Yellow and Black Gold

When we came across the Pavé Lab Grown Diamond Fashion Bangle in 14K Yellow and Black Gold, we thought, “Wow, this is original.” Surely, two shades of 14k gold and lab-grown diamond details make this accessory a conversation piece.

Trio Oval Blue Topaz Bracelet in Sterling Silver

Add a pop of color to your fine jewelry with the Trio Oval Blue Topaz Bracelet in Sterling Silver, a lovely option that’s less than $750. Other gemstones are available as well and set in a flexible triple-line design.

Earrings

Vertical Diamond Row Hoops in 14K Yellow Gold

Elegant and classic is the name of the game. The Vertical Diamond Row Hoops in 14K Yellow Gold is the quintessential pair for everyday wear, whether off to work or to weekend brunch. They add the perfect amount of sparkle with their diamond row, too.

Luna Sapphire and Diamond Hoop Earrings in 18K White Gold

We can’t stay away from sapphire as it’s sophisticated, regal-looking and supremely elegant. Shop the Luna Sapphire and Diamond Hoop Earrings in 18K White Gold, one of Blue Nile’s finest, for a pair she’ll wear 24/7.

South Sea Pearl and Pavé Diamond Wrap Drop Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold

If you’re not a fan of large, chunky pearl earrings, the South Sea Pearl and Pavé Diamond Wrap Drop Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold is a dainty pair that complements a variety of styles. Specifically, this pair is suspended from gold hoops and elegantly wrapped with swirling diamond-studded details for a refined, beautiful look.

Bamboo Huggie Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold

Add some shape to your jewelry collection with the Bamboo Huggie Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold. The quality is surely there, as this pair is suitable for every age and keenly designed with some unique curvature.

Pear and Marquise Lab Grown Diamond Round Leaf Drop Earrings in 14K White Gold

Dazzle the night away with the Pear and Marquise Lab Grown Diamond Round Leaf Drop Earrings in 14K White Gold, one of the most attention-grabbing earrings Blue Nile has to offer. Combining multiple diamond shapes, they’re one-of-a-kind.

Necklaces

Three-Stone Drop Diamond Pendant in 18K Rose Gold

Simplistic and dainty, the Three-Stone Drop Diamond Pendant in 18K Rose Gold is a lovely option for anyone on your shopping list this year. We deem it the perfect size and love its three round brilliant-cut diamonds in graduated sizes.

Lab Grown Diamond Heart Pendant in 14K Yellow Gold

Show your loved one just how much you love them with the Lab Grown Diamond Heart Pendant in 14K Yellow Gold, a gift they’ll treasure forever. Its brilliant round lab-grown diamonds are suspended from a classic cable chain, making it one of the most romantic fine jewelry pieces on this list.

Kite Set Solitaire Diamond Pendant in 14K White Gold

For the minimalist jewelry lover you know, splurge on the Kite Set Solitaire Diamond Pendant in 14K White Gold that she’ll never want to take off. It’s available in a rich variety of carat sizes and metals, making it fit for anyone you’re shopping for.

Blue Nile Signature Princess-Cut Diamond Cross Pendant in Platinum

If your loved one has been wanting a new cross, look no further than the Blue Nile Signature Princess-Cut Diamond Cross Pendant in Platinum. Specifically, this pendant showcases 2 carats of brilliant Blue Nile Signature Ideal Cut Princess diamonds set in a classic platinum design. It’s also accompanied with a versatile adjustable length matching chain. 

Freshwater Cultured Pearl Strand Necklace in 14K White Gold

For less than $1,000, we can’t stop glossing over the Freshwater Cultured Pearl Strand Necklace in 14K White Gold that Audrey Hepburn would greatly approve of. Matching with all of your worktops and holiday dresses, it’s a timepiece that will never go out of style.

For over 200 years, the New York Post has been America’s go-to source for bold news, engaging stories, in-depth reporting, and now, insightful shopping guidance. We’re not just thorough reporters – we sift through mountains of information, test and compare products, and consult experts on any topics we aren’t already schooled specialists in to deliver useful, realistic product recommendations based on our extensive and hands-on analysis. Here at The Post, we’re known for being brutally honest – we clearly label partnership content, and whether we receive anything from affiliate links, so you always know where we stand. We routinely update content to reflect current research and expert advice, provide context (and wit) and ensure our links work. Please note that deals can expire, and all prices are subject to change.